Best Burgers in Goshen NY
- Franz Brendle
- Aug 12
- 2 min read
Updated: Aug 15

Is the best burger in Orange County, NY at Pharmacy Kitchen & Bar?
Finding the "best" burger is a quest that can take a lifetime. Everyone has their own criteria, from the perfect sear on the patty to the ideal bun-to-meat ratio. But if you're in Orange County, New York, and haven't yet been to Pharmacy Kitchen & Bar in Goshen, your search may have just come to a delicious end. This isn't just a restaurant; it's a culinary experience that has quietly created a burger masterpiece. And they proclaim the best burger in Goshen NY
Here’s why Pharmacy's burger has earned its reputation as a serious contender for the best in the county:
1. A Dedication to Quality Ingredients
The foundation of any great burger is the meat, and Pharmacy Kitchen & Bar takes this seriously. They're part of the growing movement to source ingredients locally, a philosophy that ensures freshness and supports the community. Everything is prepared in-house from scratch, giving them total control over the flavor profile and quality. This isn't just a patty thrown on a grill; it's a carefully crafted piece of culinary art.
2. The Fire-Grilled Difference
One of the most notable features that sets their burgers apart is the cooking method. The burgers are fire-grilled, which imparts a smoky, robust flavor that you simply can't get from a flat-top griddle. The high heat creates a beautiful, crusty sear on the outside while locking in the juices, ensuring every bite is a perfect balance of smoky char and tender, savory meat.
3. The Simplicity of a Masterpiece
While they offer a variety of creative options like the "Surf and Turf" burger, which adds succulent lobster, their classic Pharmacy Burger is a testament to the power of simplicity done right. It's not overloaded with a mountain of unnecessary toppings. Instead, it relies on the exceptional quality of the patty, a perfectly toasted bun, and fresh, crisp vegetables to let the natural flavors shine. This is a burger that respects its ingredients.
4. The Expertise Behind the Counter
The restaurant's commitment to excellence is no accident. With a chef who trained in New York City, Pharmacy Kitchen & Bar brings a level of culinary sophistication to Goshen that elevates familiar dishes. This professional expertise is evident in every aspect of the burger, from the seasoning of the meat to the balance of flavors.
5. The Vibe: A Perfect Pairing
The experience of eating a great burger is about more than just the food. Pharmacy Kitchen & Bar offers a chic, modern, yet comfortable ambiance. It's a place where you can enjoy a beautifully made cocktail or a local craft beer alongside your meal. This makes it an ideal spot for a casual lunch, a date night, or a gathering with friends, where the food is always the star of the show.
The Verdict
While other spots in the region, have their own devoted followers, Pharmacy Kitchen & Bar offers a unique combination of exceptional quality, masterful cooking techniques, and a standout atmosphere. For anyone on a mission to find Orange County's best burger, a trip to this Goshen gem is a non-negotiable stop on your journey. You might just find yourself agreeing that the quest is over.



Comments