Pharmacy Kitchen and Bar - among the Best Restaurants in Goshen

Great Times

Nestled in the heart of Goshen, New York, Pharmacy Kitchen and Bar stands out as a culinary beacon in Orange County NY, drawing food enthusiasts from nearby Middletown and beyond. Housed in a beautifully restored 1861 pharmacy building, this modern chophouse combines historic charm with contemporary flair, offering wood-fired dishes, dry-aged steaks, and inventive cocktails that celebrate local Hudson Valley ingredients. Whether you're a local seeking a standout date night or a visitor exploring the region, here's why Pharmacy Kitchen and Bar earns its spot among the best restaurants in Goshen.

A Historic Setting with Modern Vibes

The restaurant's location in a 19th-century pharmacy isn't just a gimmick—it's the soul of the place. Revitalized by longtime Goshen residents, the space pays homage to its roots with subtle nods to its apothecary past, like "elixirs" on the cocktail menu and a warm, inviting ambiance that blends exposed brick, cozy seating, and an open kitchen centered around a wood-burning grill. This historic backdrop creates a unique atmosphere that's perfect for everything from intimate dinners to group gatherings, including a spacious second-floor event space for private parties. Just a short drive from Middletown (about 15 minutes), it's an easy escape for those in the area looking for something beyond chain restaurants, with a vibe that's lively yet relaxed—think great music, friendly staff, and a sense of community that makes you feel right at home.

Exceptional Wood-Fired Cuisine

Using Local Flavors At the core of Pharmacy Kitchen and Bar's appeal is its commitment to high-quality, locally sourced fare prepared over live fire. The menu showcases Hudson Valley produce, finest meats, fish, and poultry, all handled by classically trained chefs who emphasize bold, smoky flavors. Standouts include the Pharmacy Burger , a juicy, wood-grilled patty that's a customer favorite for its simplicity and taste, and the GOAT Burger, which elevates the classic with premium ingredients. Appetizers like fried provolone or wings—often hailed as some of the best in the Hudson Valley—set the tone, while mains such as dry-aged steaks and seasonal small plates highlight the restaurant's steakhouse expertise. Don't skip the sides, like fries cooked in beef tallow for extra crispiness, or desserts that round out the meal sweetly. What sets the food apart is the focus on regional ingredients, turning simple dishes into memorable experiences. Reviews frequently praise the "perfectly prepared" entrees, bursting with herbs and flavors, and the overall value—dishes are reasonably priced for the quality, making it accessible for both casual outings and special occasions. Their own blog even touts it as offering the best food in Orange County, with wings that customers rave about for their crunch and seasoning.

Signature Cocktails and a Welcoming Bar Scene

No visit is complete without exploring the bar, where "Barmacists" craft signature elixirs using fresh-squeezed juices, house-made bitters, tinctures, and local craft spirits. The cocktail menu is inventive and ties back to the pharmacy theme, with drinks that are as visually stunning as they are delicious—think bourbon nights on Whiskey Wednesdays or refreshing options for brunch. Beer and wine selections complement the offerings, and the bar often buzzes with energy, especially on weekends when it's open late (until 10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays). It's a spot where you can unwind with a handcrafted drink while watching the open kitchen in action, adding to the immersive dining experience.

Glowing Reviews and Community Love

Diners consistently highlight Pharmacy Kitchen and Bar for its great service, delicious food, and inviting decor. People often emphasize "wonderful service, friendly staff, delicious food and drinks," with many noting it's ideal for groups or couples. On platforms like Yelp and Facebook, patrons share stories of memorable meals, from business dinners to holiday parties, praising the attentive staff and fun atmosphere. With 5-star shoutouts for everything from the mimosas at brunch to the piping-hot, flavorful plates Pharmacy is a local standout. In a region full of dining options, its blend of history, quality, and local pride makes it a standout—often recommended as a "gem" in Orange County. If you're in Goshen or cruising from Middletown, make a reservation at Pharmacy Kitchen and Bar (62 West Main Street, Goshen, NY). It's more than a meal—it's a taste of the Hudson Valley's best, wrapped in a historic package. Pro tip: Go on a Wednesday for whiskey specials or Sunday for brunch. You won't be disappointed!