The Best Food in Orange County NY

Nestled in the charming town of Goshen, New York, Pharmacy Kitchen and Bar stands out as a culinary gem in Orange County. Housed in a historic building dating back to 1861—originally an actual pharmacy—this restaurant blends nostalgia with modern sophistication. But what truly sets it apart isn't just the quirky theme (think cocktails served in syringes and bills in prescription bottles); it's the exceptional food that keeps locals and visitors coming back. From wood-fired masterpieces to inventive dishes crafted with locally sourced ingredients, Pharmacy Kitchen and Bar delivers an experience that's both elevated and approachable. Here's why I believe it boasts the best food in the county. ## 1. Commitment to Fresh, Locally Sourced Ingredients At the heart of Pharmacy's menu is a dedication to quality ingredients. The restaurant prides itself on using locally sourced produce, along with the finest meats, fish, and poultry available. This farm-to-table approach ensures every dish bursts with freshness and flavor, supporting local farmers while minimizing the carbon footprint. In an era where mass-produced food dominates, Pharmacy's focus on seasonal and regional elements elevates simple ingredients into something extraordinary. Whether it's the vibrant veggies in their bowls or the premium cuts for their steaks, you can taste the difference in every bite. ## 2. The Magic of Wood-Fired Cooking What makes Pharmacy's food truly unforgettable is their wood-burning grill, the undisputed star of the open kitchen. Using a hand-fabricated Argentinian parilla grill, the chefs impart a smoky, charred perfection to their dishes that's hard to replicate. Steaks are a highlight here—options like the 18-ounce aged New York strip, filet mignon, or the massive 32-ounce porterhouse are cooked to juicy perfection and served with house-made sauces or butters. But it's not just about the meats; even burgers and tacos get that irresistible wood-fired touch. This technique adds depth and complexity, turning everyday eats into gourmet delights. ## 3. An Innovative and Eclectic Menu Pharmacy's menu defies easy categorization—it's a playful mix of comfort food with upscale twists. Starters like truffled deviled eggs or Hudson Valley duck confit tacos with fire-roasted tomato salsa and kimchi showcase creativity and global influences. For heartier fare, try the Pharmacy burger with house-cut fries or the surf-and-turf version loaded with lobster. Bowl options, such as tuna poke or slow-braised short-rib Hungarian goulash over spaetzle, offer comforting yet refined choices. Sides like creamed spinach or truffle parmesan risotto round out the experience. No matter what you order, the portions are generous, and the flavors are bold and balanced. It's this versatility that makes Pharmacy accessible for a casual night out or a special occasion. ## 4. Expert Chef and a Storied Background Behind the scenes is Chef Franz Brendle, whose classical training and experience shine through in every plate. Previously at the helm of acclaimed spots like the Zagat-listed Nina in Middletown and Craft 47 in Goshen, Brendle brings a wealth of expertise to Pharmacy. Co-owned with Karyn Scordo, the restaurant opened its doors in July 2020 amid pandemic challenges and has since become a staple, seating up to 95 guests in its moody, urbane space. Brendle's passion for wood-fired cuisine and inventive pairings ensures consistency and innovation, making each visit feel fresh. ## 5. Complemented by Craft Cocktails and Atmosphere While the food takes center stage, Pharmacy's handcrafted cocktails—dubbed "elixirs" and mixed by "Barmacists"—perfectly complement the menu. Using fresh-squeezed juices, house-made bitters, and local craft spirits, drinks like the mezcal-based Afrin or the whiskey-infused Vitamin C add a fun, thematic flair. The atmosphere, with its edgy decor featuring old medicine bottles and drugstore ephemera, creates an inviting vibe that's both street-wise and elegant. Reviews rave about the great service, lively music, and overall comfort, making it a spot where the food shines even brighter in context. Of course, no place is perfect—some patrons note higher prices relative to portions or occasional inconsistencies—but the overwhelming feedback is positive, with many highlighting it as a must-visit for its quality and care. It's even earned 5-star shoutouts for the attention to detail in every plate and pour. In a county brimming with dining options, Pharmacy Kitchen and Bar rises above with its blend of history, innovation, and sheer deliciousness. If you're in Orange County, NY, do yourself a favor and grab a reservation—your taste buds will thank you. Whether it's the smoky steaks, creative tacos, or that perfect cocktail, this spot proves that great food is the best medicine. Find out for yourself if they have the best food in Orange County NY